How to Build Confidence in a Spooky Horse

Halloween is almost here, and that means it’s the season of spooky surprises. If your horse has ever slammed on the brakes at a rogue pumpkin or darted sideways at a flapping scarecrow, you’re not alone! Horses are flight animals, and spooking is a totally natural reaction. But that doesn’t mean we enjoy a spooky horse—we can help our horses become more confident, even in the face of Halloween horrors like… our homemade scarecrow or those regular, everyday scary ghosts in the corner of the arena!

In this video, I walk you through three practical strategies to build trust and get your horse past spooky objects safely and confidently. Whether you’re riding past spooky decorations at home or navigating a new arena filled with ghosts and goblins, these tips will help you turn your horse’s spook into curiosity.

1. Establish Control in the “Safe Zone”

Before you even think about approaching the scary object, start in a part of the arena where your horse feels relaxed. This is your safe zone—use it to check in with your horse. Can you bend and turn left and right? Are they paying attention to you? If not, don’t venture closer yet. Get the connection and responsiveness first, so you’re in a position to support your horse when things get spooky. Trying to take control after a spook happens is way too late—prepare before you approach.

2. Zigzag Your Way to Confidence

Once you’ve got control, don’t ride directly at the terrifying Halloween scarecrow (or whatever your horse is worried about). Instead, zigzag your approach. Horses have incredible peripheral vision, so let them see the object from different angles—first out of their left eye, then the right. You’ll likely notice they’re most nervous when they’re looking at it straight on with both eyes. That’s okay! Use this moment to encourage curiosity, not panic. Ride past, pet them, and then move away before they feel overwhelmed. You want to always be the one making the decision to retreat—never wait for your horse to bolt.

3. Don’t Be Afraid to Get Off

Let’s be honest—not every rider feels like a superhero when facing a haunted-looking obstacle. If your confidence starts to waver, that’s a good time to hop off and work from the ground. Do some basic groundwork, ask your horse to lower their head, and walk them up to the object calmly. Touch it yourself. Let them see you interacting with it safely. This builds trust and shows your horse there’s nothing to fear. Once they’re calm, you can remount and ride by with more confidence.

Remember: Spooky Season is Training Season

Don’t wait for your horse to “get over it” or hope they’ll spook less next time. These moments are golden opportunities to teach your horse that scary things aren’t dangerous—and that they can trust you.

Happy riding!

Amelia

P.S. Want more help with spooky situations? Establishing trust and communication with your horse on the ground first is the best way to help you handle spooky situations with confidence. Join my Free Groundwork Webinar, where I’ll guide you through the key techniques for building trust, focus, and a better partnership with your horse. Click here to sign up!

ABOUT YOUR INSTRUCTOR
A smiling woman wearing a helmet and riding gear stands beside a chestnut horse with a black bridle and white saddle pad, holding its reins outdoors in a sunlit, green setting.
Hey there.
I'm Amelia Newcomb
At Amelia Newcomb Dressage, I work to develop a trusting and confident relationship between horse and rider. I draw on theories from both natural horsemanship and classical dressage, creating a holistic training approach that adapts to the unique needs of each horse and rider.
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
RELATED POSTS
Like this article & video?

There are hundreds more! View the entire library here.

A person in equestrian gear teaches a white horse how to do a leg yield from the ground. Perfect for a round of fitness training over 30 days.
FEATURED COURSE
Groundwork Essentials
Establish trust and communication with your horse with Groundwork Essentials. Learn to read body language and redirect attention in as little as 5 minutes per day. Simple, practical, and effective exercises to get any horse relaxed and focused.
A person wearing a helmet and blue patterned shirt stands outdoors holding the reins of two brown horses, one on each side, with trees and bushes in the background—like a perfect image for a Sales Page Template.
Amelia Newcomb
LATEST POSTS
LATEST YOUTUBE VIDEO
Rated 5 out of 5
NEWSLETTER

Sign Up Now To Get Free Training & Tips In Your Inbox!

🔥 HOT RIGHT NOW 🔥
Explore More with Our Featured Courses and Workshops

We’ve curated a selection of courses, workshops, and masterclasses designed to help you refine your skills and achieve your riding goals. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to advance, these offerings are here to support your growth. Explore and take your riding education to the next level!

Establish trust and communication with your horse with Groundwork Essentials. Learn to read body language and redirect attention in as little as 5 minutes per day. Simple, practical, and effective exercises to get any horse relaxed and focused.
Dressage is full of figures, patterns, and exercises that we use to train our horses, improve suppleness, and as tools to help them learn what we are asking of them. When you ride figures accurately, your horse becomes on the aids and becomes more supple, connected, and responsive. In this workshop, you will learn about some of my favorite figures and how to use them to help your horse.
Tired of riding with tension? Suppleness means "elasticity and freedom from anxiety" and in this workshop you will learn how to do just that. A supple horse is relaxed in body and mind and is able to work optimally without tension - this is the feeling we all love when we're riding!

Enjoyed this article? 

Saddle Up and Search for Your Next Read!
A person wearing a helmet and patterned shirt smiles while riding a brown horse outdoors on a sunny day, with green trees in the blurred background.
Free Resources
Unlock Your Potential as a Dressage Rider with Our Free Resources!

Are you passionate about dressage and eager to enhance your skills? Our Free Resources section is here to support your journey, offering a wide range of courses, guides, and tools designed to help you become the rider you’ve always wanted to be.

Access Now!
A simple white envelope icon on a light background, outlined with bold lines to represent a closed envelope.
Free Training & Tips In Your Inbox!

Say goodbye to the fluff and hello to real value. Our newsletter delivers actionable insights, expert tips, and the kind of motivation that pushes you to the next level in your dressage journey. Ready to make strides in your riding? Let’s do this—straight to your inbox. You in?

Join the community

Get weekly training to your Inbox

Enter your name and email below and you’ll be added to my list to get weekly training videos each week. You’ll also be the first to hear about all my news, courses and offers! You can unsubscribe at any time!

PS-Good things are coming. Please be patient with this form, it sometimes takes a moment to submit your details!

Free PDF:

10 Dressage Terms

Every Rider Should Know

Understanding the Language of Dressage is the Key to Real Progress

Please be patient with this form, it sometimes takes a moment to submit your details!